In Rare Victory, Christian Wins Compensation in Out-of-Court Settlement of Civil Suit Against Lhasa Police

China Aid Association
(Lhasa, Tibet—April 6, 2012) In a rare victory, a Christian who sued the police in Lhasa for criminally detaining him for a month, forcing him to write a guarantee before releasing him, and confiscating church and personal items won compensation in an out-of-court settlement on Thursday.

A hearing was scheduled for Friday in the suit filed by Song Kuanxin, a missionary to the Tibetan capital of Lhasa who is originally from Zhumudian, Henan province. He was represented by prominent Christian lawyer Zhang Kai, who is well-known for handling other high-profile cases. The day before the scheduled hearing, the Tibet Public Security Bureau said it wanted to settle out of court.

(File photo of lawyer Zhang Kai in court)

When the two sides sat down to talk, the Lhasa police offered to return all the confiscated church and personal items, including confiscated personal items belonging to other church members who did not join Song in the suit because of fear or for other reasons. The police also agreed to pay 7000 yuan (US$1110)  in compensation for losses caused by the illegal law enforcement actions by the police, including expenses for travel and partial payment for missing theology books. Song and his house church agreed, bringing the suit to a close.

On Oct. 5, 2011, Song was picked up by Lhasa police, who on Oct. 7 criminally detained him “on suspicion of [being part of a] cult group.” He was held with convicted felons, and was later notified that his detention was being extended to 30 days for “committing crimes everywhere.” While Song was in detention, police officers blasphemed and insulted his faith and repeatedly beat him.

On Nov. 11, after being forced to write a guarantee, Song was released early. However, he was told that all the belongings that police had confiscated from his home, including two laptops, were considered tools for his criminal activities and had been destroyed.

See ChinaAid’s earlier report: https://chinaaid.org/2011/12/in-historic-first-authorities-detain.html

Song later wrote a detailed account of this case of persecution and distributed it widely on the Internet. He was one of 11 Christians in Lhasa who were detained by police around the Oct. 1 National Day holiday, believed to be the first time Christians in Tibet had been arrested, and the case drew wide attention among China’s house churches.
(Photo: Lawyer Zhang Kai with orphans adopted by Christians in Lhasa.)

The satisfactory conclusion to Song’s suit, especially coming as it did at the end of Holy Week and just a few days before Easter, the most joyous day of the Christian calendar, was a great encouragement to China’s house churches. ChinaAid founder and president Bob Fu expressed his approval of the outcome of this case and said he hoped that police and other law enforcement personnel in the rest of China would learn from the example of the Lhasa Public Security, by recognizing mistakes and correcting them so as to rectify illegal acts committed in the process of law enforcement. Doing so would promote improvements in China’s human rights, rule of law and freedom of religion.

Lawyer Zhang Kai, who handled the infamous “My father is Li Gang” hit-and-run case that shocked the nation, tweeted the good news on his Weibo account yesterday and called on Public Security organs throughout China to follow the example of the Lhasa Public Security Bureau. See his tweet below:

[Translation of above—Lawyer Zhang Kai: Good news. Our civil suit in Lhasa, suing the Lhasa police. Today, the Lhasa police not only returned the confiscated items, they also paid compensation. We express deep appreciation to the Lhasa Public Security for recognizing their mistakes and correcting them and their timely correction. The entire Public Security system of the whole country should learn from the Lhasa Public Security. This way of resolving the problem is in accordance both with the law and with Party policy. May God bless Lhasa. ]

China Aid Contacts
Rachel Ritchie, English Media Director
Cell: (432) 553-1080 | Office: 1+ (888) 889-7757 | Other: (432) 689-6985
Email: [email protected]
Website: www.chinaaid.org